By continuing to browse our site, you are consenting to the use of cookies. Click here for more information on the cookies we use.


Defending life
from conception to natural death


weekly update, 16 January

16 January 2008

weekly update, 16 January Mr Gordon Brown, the British prime minister, has expressed his support for a system of presumed consent for organ donation. This would mean that the organs of any person could be used for transplants after their death, unless they or their relatives specifically opted out. Britain currently operates a system whereby people must opt in to being organ donors. [BBC, 13 January ] John Smeaton, SPUC's national director, said: "In an opt-out system, where most people's wishes are unknown, consent is absent and you can't really speak of organ donation any more. An opt-out system also represents a high level of interference by the state in personal life. The dead person's body effectively becomes government property. The worst situation would be where people's deaths could actually be hastened because their organs were needed for someone else. The evidence seems equivocal about whether such a change would increase the number of organs available. Some countries with opt-out systems do worse than the UK but some do better." [SPUC, 14 January ] Rt Rev Tom Butler, Anglican bishop of Southwark, said a presumed consent system should not be introduced until every effort has been made to increase organ donation under the current system. [Telegraph, 14 January ] Members of the House of Lords have been debating a UK government bill which would consolidate and extend the killing and abuse of early human life. SPUC's John Smeaton said: "The Government have tabled amendments aimed at making the bill sound better and at the same time trying to reduce any opposition to its main provisions. Anti-life Peers have also tabled some amendments to extend even further the scope of destructive embryo experimentation. In addition, some Peers have tabled amendments seeking to remove or ameliorate some aspects. Unfortunately, the bill is so fundamentally flawed, no amendments can make it ethical. "Whatever amendments may be agreed, pro-life supporters should lobby parliamentarians to urge them to oppose the bill in principle and as a whole." [SPUC, 15 January ] A Northern Irish parliamentarian has warned that the bill will lead to "Frankenstein science". Lord Morrow, chairman of the Democratic Unionist Party, said: "The sanctity of human life is an issue which transcends any party political considerations. We tinker with the delicate fabric of human life at our peril and any moves which would undermine or reduce the value which we place on it must be resisted at all costs." [Belfast Telegraph, 9 January ] SPUC has asked Mr Tony Blair, the former British prime minister, if he will repudiate some of his previous political actions now that he has become a Catholic. John Smeaton, SPUC national director, has written to Mr Blair to ask him to admit that he was wrong to support abortion up to birth, abortions on girls as young as 11 without parents' knowledge, requiring doctors to dehydrate their patients to death, the promotion of abortion as a human right and destructive experiments on human embryos. John Smeaton said: "While many of our Catholic members will be pleased to hear of anyone's conversion to their church, we have concerns about how Mr Blair behaved. This is an opportunity for him to come clean and give witness to the pro-life stance, which we earnestly hope he has now embraced. We would hope that, in his various new roles on the world stage, Mr Blair might try to undo some of the harm he has done." [SPUC, 11 January ] A senior Irish obstetrician has called for improved provision of pre-natal screening for congenital defects in Ireland. Professor Fergal Malone, chairman of the department of obstetrics and gynaecology at the Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland and the Rotunda Hospital, Dublin, said there was a need for more trained personnel to carry out ultrasound screening, and a national programme to make it widely available. Ireland is said to have the highest rate of Downs syndrome in the EU. [Sunday Business Post, 13 January ] In Britain, the NHS has a nationwide screening programme and 90% of babies with Down's are aborted. Some girls and women travel from Ireland to Britain for abortion. IVF clinics in Britain will have to reveal the likely costs of treatment to patients before they start to provide it, under new regulations from the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority. The decision came after a survey of 1,000 current and former IVF patients, which showed that, while 85% of patients paid for treatment themselves, only 20% of them were given a costed plan at the outset and more than 25% had to pay fees that they had not expected. [Times, 9 January ]

Be the first to comment!

Share this article