News, 25 July 2002
Baroness Warnock, whose report on human fertilisation and embryology in
the 1980s led to the statutory approval of IVF and destructive embryo
research in the UK, has said that infertile men should be allowed to
clone themselves for the purpose of reproduction. In her book entitled
Making Babies, which will be published next month, Baroness Warnock
argues that so-called reproductive cloning should be outlawed in every
case "except perhaps in cases of complete male infertility, when all
other remedies have failed". [
The Herald, 25 July]
The US House of Representatives yesterday passed the latest legislation
to ban partial-birth abortions by 274 votes to 151. It received
bipartisan support with 65 Democrats voting in favour, but reports
suggest that Tom Daschle, the pro-abortion majority leader in the
Senate, may try to avoid debate on the legislation in the Senate.
President Clinton vetoed bans on partial-birth abortion passed by both
the House of Representatives and the Senate on two occasions, but
President Bush has signalled his strong support for a ban. The White
House has said that it is "morally imperative and constitutionally
permissible to prohibit this very abhorrent form of abortion". [
PR Newswire, 24 July;
AP, 25 July]
The European Patent Office has moved to close a loophole which could
theoretically have allowed the cloning of transgenic humans for
reproductive purposes. The governments of Germany, Italy and the
Netherlands were among those who complained to the agency that a patent
awarded to the creators of Dolly the sheep could have applied to humans
as well as to animals. The patent awarded to Edinburgh university and
Stem Cell Sciences, an Australian company, gave permission for the
creation of transgenic mammals whose cells had been altered. However,
the language of the patent did not explicitly exclude its application
to humans. [
BBC, 24 July]
A fertility specialist has warned that mistakes and mix-ups at IVF
clinics in Britain are an everyday occurrence. Dr Sammy Lee, a
scientific consultant at the Portland hospital in London, said: "Every
day, someone somewhere in the UK is inadvertently messing up... I am
aware of the wrong embryos being transferred to the wrong patients at
several NHS units during the past 10 years. I have also confidentially
been told about a number of cases where the wrong sperm were used to
inseminate eggs." [
BBC, 24 July]
A spokesman for SPUC commented: "The public is understandably concerned
about mix-ups in IVF clinics, but of even greater concern is the fact
that the vast majority of babies created by IVF die in the aftermath."
An opinion poll has indicated that only a minority of Americans
support the 1973 US Supreme Court decisions in Roe v Wade and Doe v
Bolton which declared a constitutional right to abortion up to birth.
An opinion poll conducted by Gallup has found that only 25% to 27% of
the population believe that abortion should be "legal under any
circumstances". 51% to 54% believe that abortion should be legal but
"only under certain circumstances". 86% support restrictions on
abortion in the third trimester, and 62% support restrictions in the
second trimester. Only 11% are opposed to informed consent laws which
require doctors to inform women about the alternatives to abortion
before proceeding with a termination. [
LifeSite, 24 July]
To subscribe to SPUC's email information services, please visit www.spuc.org.uk/em-signup. The reliability of the news herein is dependent on that of the cited sources, which are paraphrased rather than quoted. Opinions expressed are not necessarily those of the society. © Society for the Protection of Unborn Children, 2012