In a letter to every Catholic bishop in all EU member- and applicant
member-states, John Smeaton, SPUC national director, has explained
that the draft constitution's rights of 'human dignity' and 'physical
and mental integrity', as well as a weakened and subordinated article
on the right to life, "may well lead to a 'right to die' and the
killing of those humans commonly misrepresented as 'non-persons'.
Mr Smeaton also warned that "because of the vague 'rights' and broad
judicial power created by the draft Constitution, the document may
limit democratic (that is, legislative) debate and decision-making at
national levels. Decisions regarding important social and moral
questions will be determined by the European Court of Justice rather
than national parliaments."
Mr Smeaton called for both civil and religious leaders "to raise these
concerns at the highest political levels" both nationally and at the
EU, and proposed amendments to the draft constitution designed to
ensure legal protection for human life.
The letter is on the SPUC website as a PDF file at www.spuc.org.uk/lobbying/eubishops.pdf.