News, 7 July 2000
It has emerged that researchers in Britain are circumventing the
present ban on all human cloning by importing embryo stem cells from
the United States. The cells, stored in dry ice, were imported from
Wisconsin several months ago and were taken from discarded embryos
produced by in vitro fertilisation treatment. Professor Peter Andrews
of Sheffield University, who is conducting the research, said that the
loophole showed the British government was being hypocritical in its
approach. Paul Tully, general secretary of the Society for the
Protection of Unborn Children, commented: "The lack of a sound moral
principle underpinning our embryology laws is bound to lead to all
sorts of anomalies." [BBC News online, 6 July; Daily Express, 7 July;
The Guardian, 7 July] Similar plans by German scientists to import
embryo stem cells from the United States were reported in this digest
on 21 June.
The Catholic bishops of Ireland have told the all-party committee on
the constitution which is currently looking into the abortion issue
that the Irish constitution must be changed to include a specific ban
on abortion. The existing constitutional wording was interpreted by the
Irish Supreme Court in a way which allowed a teenage girl to have an
abortion when she threatened suicide. The bishops described this
judgement as seriously flawed, and warned that if it were allowed to
stand, or enacted into legislation, the fundamental principle that
every human life is of value in itself would be lost. Bishop Laurence
Ryan of Kildare and Leighlin said: "We believe that what is required is
a constitutional amendment that would protect the right to life of the
unborn child, while recognising that an expectant mother who is ill
must receive such medical treatment as is necessary, even when that
treatment, as a side-effect, puts her unborn child at risk." [Catholic
World News, 6 July]
An Italian couple from Trapani who are expecting septets (seven babies)
have refused an offer by doctors to abort some of their unborn
children. Mariella Mazzara, aged 31, conceived unexpectedly while
taking fertility drugs after in vitro fertilisation had failed. She was
offered abortions after being told that otherwise she could lose all
the babies, but she responded by saying, "Who are we to decide which
embryos should be eliminated? We hope for the natural evolution of the
pregnancy." Giovanni Pirrera, aged 32 and father of the septets, said:
"We accept all the children that God gives us and, if the Lord wills,
we will be given the grace to carry on with the pregnancy, there is
nothing else to say." [Zenit news agency, 6 July]
An auxiliary bishop in the Catholic archdiocese of Toronto has
criticised the Catholic Women's League in Ontario for omitting to
include in its upcoming convention's information pack comments by
bishops who oppose the March of Women 2000. Bishop Nicola De Angelis,
the League's spiritual advisor in Ontario, was concerned that the pack
included statements in support of the march, such as from the Canadian
Bishops' Conference, but not comments by bishops who object to
participation in a march which will include pro-abortion groups. Betty
Anne Brown, president of the Ontario CWL, responded in her own letter
by saying, "I am sorry that you promulgated your opinion without
passing it by me first," and added, "We are an autonomous women's
organisation in which males do not have a vote on policy." She insisted
that the CWL has always been pro-life, but accused "anti-abortion
people" of being "jealous of our influence and the fact that we are
listened to by governments." "It is they who are trying to discredit
us. We will not fall to their smear campaigns," she wrote. [Catholic
World News, 6 July]
To subscribe to SPUC's email information services, please visit www.spuc.org.uk/em-signup. The reliability of the news herein is dependent on that of the cited sources, which are paraphrased rather than quoted. Opinions expressed are not necessarily those of the society. © Society for the Protection of Unborn Children, 2010